I never thought James Gunn was the right fit for the DCU.
Not, at least, going by my outdated perceptions of the brand, which was built on squeaky clean 1970s comics, Christopher Reeve’s Superman, Lynda Carter’s Wonder Woman, and Superfriends (Wonder Twin powers activate!).
That impression didn't jive at all with Gunn's despicable, vulgar, misogynistic 'Justice Gang' louts (See Peacemaker's interview).
Frankly, though, I didn’t think Snyder was a good fit either.
Both James Gunn and Zack Snyder are incredible craftsmen with instantly identifiable styles. Snyder is stronger on aesthetics, Gunn the better writer, but both brought a strong personal vision to their iterations of the DCU. Whatever your opinion of their projects, there was more to them than just crass commercialism.
Sadly, Snyder’s universe derailed, and Gunn’s has been strangled in the crib.
I don’t think this bodes well for the future of the brand’s cinematic forays.
Incoming CEO Jeremy ‘Would-my-grandmother-like-it’ Latcham looks to make the safest, broadest appeal DCU possible, and for films that now routinely cost $200-300 million dollars, that sounds smart. And I actually would like a greater focus on 'hope'. A new tranche of safe, pulled-punch flicks may indeed appeal to our grandma archetype.
Except she’s dead now: we’ve had 25+ years worth of superhero cinema tsunamis, including multiple reboots.
Even reboots on the reboots.
Honestly, every time they rebooted Spiderman I lost more interest, and frankly I can’t be bothered anymore. Reboot the entire universe and you alienate casual viewers from your creative car crash. Their probable salvation? The eternally upcoming generation of 10 year old consumers who don't know any better.
And to be fair, that's kind of how the system works.
Paradoxically, 'safe', idealized and hopeful versions of my favourite DC heroes may actually fit my childhood mental model better.
But old me is sick of it.
I've aged out.
I don’t think David Ellison gives a crap about narrative integrity—or fans.
He cares about one thing: money.
That’s it.
Period.
Artistry be damned.
My (currently highly disgruntled) prediction?
New DC movies will be soulless, regurgitated bilge, the safest imaginable mush possible, the creative equivalent of baby food. The corporate version of ever-cheery Chinese Communist Party propaganda. That stuff is such pure, ultra-refined positivity it's like mainlining refined utopian idealism directly into the brain.
And if Ellison can make flicks only using sycophantic AI, he will; the possibility of eliminating the unruly ‘human factor’ from the production process will make him positively orgasmic as he reaps the cost savings and makes more money that he will never spend.
For him, people are disposable ants.
If people don’t buy what he's selling, the wheel will turn, and it’ll all be rebooted again.
And again.
And again.
Welcome to Samsara, Sisyphus. Time to get off the wheel!